Last night, I heard her screaming again, and finally had enough: "HEY!" I yelled back, "You do realize we can ALL hear you, right?" She stopped. Briefly.
The next thing I heard made my blood run cold. As she screamed about how she'd "fucking had enough of [someone's] bullshit" and how this person had been "doing this all fucking day" and that she was going to "teach [this person] a fucking lesson," I could hear a terrified child barely able to hiccup out repeated apologies through his or her hysteric sobs (the child was young enough I couldn't tell if it was male or female - maybe 4 or 5?). She also sounded drunk because she was slurring her words something fierce, and I know how quickly an angry drunk can spiral out of control.
What the hell had I just done? Now the woman was pissed at being "caught" (even though she's never made any attempts to conceal her anger in the past) - would she take it out on the child? Would she continue to rage, but just close the windows so the whole neighbourhood didn't hear her?
I was sick to my stomach and ended up in tears. I knew what I should do - call the police - but wasn't sure I should bother. When I was 14 or so, Mom called the police about the neighbours behind us because of a very similar recurring incident. The police claimed it was up to CPS to take care of the situation and to call them; CPS did the exact same thing, telling Mom to call the police: no one did anything. When I was 18 and working retail, I witnessed a woman scream at her daughter, hold her up by the arm, and wallop the hell out of her over and over. I called the policed, who never showed up, even though I followed this woman through the store and witnessed her continue to scream at and beat her child. The reason the police didn't attend? Apparently I used the "wrong wording" so they didn't take it seriously (never did find out what the RIGHT way to word my concern would have been).
I did end up calling the police a few minutes later (after shakily posting to Twitter and having friends confirm what I already knew I needed to do). Within 15 minutes, a police officer returned my call. However, because this happens in another building and I've never SEEN anything - only heard it - I had no idea which unit it was coming from. The officer sat in the parking lot, listening, for 15 minutes before calling me back to apologize for not being able to hear anything. I told him that I realized this would likely be the outcome, but wanted to make sure there was a record of the complaint just in case... There's no way I would be able to live with myself if I ended up reading a story in the paper about the unthinkable happening.
During this time, a dear friend gently and kindly reminded me that I didn't know the whole situation: if this was a matter of a special needs child, there was a possibility that the woman was just at the end of her rope and unable to stifle her frustration any longer. I did appreciate the reminder and do realize that I have no clue how difficult it is to parent a special needs child. At the same time, though, the woman was clearly out of control and, considering we've been listening to this almost daily for far too long, clearly needs some sort of assistance - whether with respite care to give herself a break, or with anger management.
I know that I am neither a parent nor a special needs parent, but in my not-so-humble asspinion, there is NEVER an excuse to scream and yell and curse and threaten a CHILD relentlessly. You lose your cool every once in awhile? Fine. But every. single. day? No. Just no. (And judging by the scream-a-thons on weekends, this isn't just some bedtime issue: this goes on all day long.) After being educated by people like my dear friend, I do understand that we shouldn't be so quick to judge parents of children who appear to be "out of control" or bratty because there is a very good possibility that the child does have a developmental disorder and that it's not a matter of "bad" parenting. However, where do I draw the line? What about all the stories on the news about the child that was abused for years and no one stepped in or did anything? For me, there's a HUGE difference between judging the parent of a "bratty" child without knowing the situation, and turning a blind eye to obvious verbal abuse because I don't want to get involved on the off-chance this is a special needs situation. Either way, special needs or not, there is no excuse to treat a child that way, period.
I don't know if it's my own past, my overly-sensitive and empathetic wimpy self, reading all the heartbreaking stories of abuse on Band Back Together, or what, but I do know that I couldn't just sit by and pretend I didn't know she was verbally abusing a child. I wouldn't be able to live with myself: for *me*, it would be as if I was somehow condoning her behaviour, and that's just not something I'm ever willing to do.
You absolutely did the right thing!! I once called the Child Porn hotline because a women I knew only online had mentioned that she found a child porn site on her husband's computer but said she wasn't going to do anything about it. I had "known" the woman for years via a step parenting forum and always thought she was a bit "off." So I didn't know if she was telling the truth or not...but I felt that I couldn't NOT do something about it, just in case. If she was lying about it, well then, she should know better than to say stuff like that!!
ReplyDeleteIn this situation, you've done the right thing. If the way that you've described the situation is accurate, it's not a good one and it needs to be dealt with.
ReplyDeleteYou just broke my heart. I want you to go out there and listen outside of every door and call the police again. This poor baby. I have ONE exceptionally "trying" child. And as a parent who is often at wits-end, I am not constantly screaming at him.
ReplyDeleteYou did the right thing. Keep doing it. You call them every time for that child's sake.
Don't question yourself. At. All. You calling out to her made her pause. That's good! Maybe if more people would call her out she would stop and think about what she's doing. She's probably in such a habit that, somehow, along the way she's forgotten. Forgotten to be patient. Forgotten that she's the adult and that yelling is just as hurtful and harmful as hitting. And the police stayed and listened, that's a good thing! The more people who listen the better! I know, first hand, how harmful and long-lasting emotional abuse can be. It changes what a person believes... of themselves and their worth and capabilities. I truly believe, in hindsight, that I could have been something truly spectacular... if I hadn't constantly been told I would never amount to anything. I'm so grateful for people like you. I wish someone would've said, even if just once, to my parents that they were ruining their child and that yelling hurtful things at a child is never, ever okay. Everyone gets frustrated and upset but there's a difference between being snappy... and truly hurtful. I remember being told those exact same words of "I'm sick of your fucking bullshit" for no apparent reason, leaving me, as an impressionable youth, thinking that no matter what I did it would be wrong. No child should ever have to walk on eggshells. They should be allowed to run and dream and play and the only hiccups they should ever get should be from too much laughter, not crying.
ReplyDeleteI'm proud of you for all you've done. The tears you shed for this child, I truly believe that child will feel that. That he/she will somehow be able to feel that someone cares... and they won't always feel so alone and afraid. I (heart) you!
You did the right thing. I don't give a shit if the child had special needs and she was at the end of her rope...I have THREE with special needs and have never yelled at my children with profanity like what you described...and y'know what? Even if that IS the scenario, that child still has feelings. My own mother was a piece of shit and it would have changed my life for the better if anyone would have cared enough to do what you did. Keep on calling them. I hope they listen.
ReplyDeletebabe, you didn't do anything wrong, she is out of control. calling the cops was absolutely the right thing.
ReplyDeleteYou did the right thing, period. And good on you. There's no excuse for that behaviour, none. Huge hugs
ReplyDeleteGood job. Not only in calling the police, but in speaking out about it here. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteIt's so hard to do things like this. To make that call. But as you KNOW..sometimes kids need help and they're KIDS..they don't always have the resources we do. They need someone to care. They need someone to make that call.
ReplyDeleteSometimes it's that call that can make or break a life - so picking up that phone? That's what you HAD to do. Even if it didn't get anything IMMEDIATELY done - people are aware now.
When I was doing a placement in a kindergarten classroom, a kid came in with a big bruise. When we asked him how it happened, he gave us a story and told us something that didn't really make much sense - it COULD have happened, but it was a long shot and really random. The teacher I was working with didn't want to call it in, because she didn't want to be the jackass that had someones family wrongly investigated. (In reality - if you're teaching, in healthcare or in certain professions - here, you're legally obligated to call it in - you can be sued like whoa/lose your job/etc. if it's found that you didn't..but yeah..people still hate stigma..)
Eventually, she called - and the police came out, talked to the kids and then took the kids within the hour. Apparently there was a list a mile long of accusations, evidence and things that had happened and been reported before - and this was the piece of the puzzle that was missing - that they needed, to finally be able to remove the kids from (what turned out to be..) a really awful home life. A lot of abuse of every kind - the kids, the mother, animals - and once a formal investigation was done - a lot of drugs/other bad shit was found. Basically the family was living in hell, and all that was needed was for something to tip their case file over the edge so that they could get the help they needed and get out.
So, because so many people had called before, had made complaints - they were able to piece together a larger puzzle. Each piece in a situation like this matters. Sometimes there are lots of pieces and they add up to nothing - because there is really nothing to be found - but sometimes there is a lot to be found and this sounds like this might be a situation where there is. Because emotional abuse is an awful kind of abuse. And yes, all parents get frustrated - but this seems crazy extreme. So, even if nothing happens right away. Even if you wonder why you did it. There will be a record. There will be a file. The next time it happens - it will be another piece that helps someone out there make sense of a situation. It matters. To kids who are living it? It can make a difference. Eventually. I've seen it happen. It really really can. You did a good thing, and I'm super proud of you and love you - even if it's hard or you weren't able to pinpoint exactly where it is - eventually, it'll all come out in the wash. It was the right thing to do. It really really was..and I'm so glad you're the kind of person who refuses to sit back and let this stuff happen. It's people like you that make the world a better place. Seriously.
xoxooxo
Like I told you last night... if it's happening that often, it's too often. Every parent has their moments where they lose it, but not every day.
ReplyDeleteOne thing you could do (in addition to phoning the police) is start keeping a record of how often you're hearing this go on. Time start/stop sort of thing. That's always helpful for the police to know the frequency.
I'm glad you called. I actually logged off Twitter last night after our exchange because I was becoming upset about this situation and I was in even less of a position to help than you. I agree that some parents lose their shit sometimes. I know I do. However, not every day. No way. Not like that. Not on and on. I still think something very wrong is going on. I only wish the police had got there sooner.
ReplyDeleteHu-freaking-rah! As a social worker and a mom, I thank you for calling the police. So often we worry - are we wrong? Is that really what I'm hearing/seeing? We want to be polite and to assume in the innocence and good will of people, but that's not always the case.
ReplyDeleteI am SO proud of you for standing up for that child and protecting them, whether or not it turned out that it was abuse. We have to speak out if there is any question if we want to stomp the shit out of child abuse.
I concur with the troops. you did the right thing. And Iceel got there first to say record it. I'd rather deal with the ingratitude of someone I tried to help than the guilt from knowing I didn't. Guilt is heavier.
ReplyDeleteYou did the right thing, CJ. As you learned- every one of us who have parented or baby sat has lost our cool, for 5 seconds or 5 minutes. I remember one moment where I left my son (maybe 2) unattended in our house for 2 minutes because I was so exhausted and fed up I was going to lose control. I walked out, locked the door, walked away until I cooled off, then came back and soothed him.
ReplyDeleteBut every day? You're right. That's wrong and it has to stop.
Record what you're hearing - even if the words are indistinct - tape it or record it, somehow, so that you have something the police CAN hear. And maybe follow up on.
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely you did the right thing, love! Keep calling if you keep hearing it. Sending you much love and strength.
ReplyDeleteSo, This is my take...you should have tweeted me so I paid attention.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, I don't care how to the end of a rope a parent is, belittling your child is never acceptable. And, trust me, I know the end of the rope well. You did good, Kid. You did what you needed to. You should have invited to po-po to your house to listen...that's what you should do next time.
Sending you all the love...
You did right. Never doubt that.
ReplyDeleteI would have called the cops too. Just because I'd rather be safe than sorry.
ReplyDeleteYou did the right thing, sweetie. I wish they'd been able to hear it and figure out what was happening & where.
ReplyDeleteYou absolutely did the right thing, and I think you're sure of that now. I hope you or the police can pinpoint the unit and help that child, regardless of the situation.
ReplyDeleteYou did the right thing. And I would continue to do it. At some point it WILL be heard. And maybe something can be done. Whether it's getting the mom the help and support she needs or getting the child out of the situation. I'm so proud of you.
ReplyDeleteI would say that since you have no clue if the kid was being bratty or not, or misbehaving or whatever, you would be giving this woman way too much grace to dismiss her as possibly being the mom of a special needs child who was at the end of her rope.
ReplyDeleteLoosing your cool can be understandable, but there is no excuse for continued and constant yelling, berating, and threatening. That is abuse. You absolutely did the right thing!!
You ABSOLUTELY did the right thing. I hope that in your heart, you believe you did too. <3
ReplyDeleteI believe that, knowing what we know today, it is our duty and responsibility to the children in our communities to look out for them as best we can. You did the right thing, as hard as it was to do. Even (especially?) kids with developmental issues need to be protected from an adult who is out of control. Just don't judge the parent while you are doing the best you can. But calling for help? Not to be confused with being judgmental.
ReplyDeleteYou know, in my humble but (righteous) opinion.
(((((HUGS)))))
I can get epically frustrated at my special needs son. I have yelled at him. But not every day, and not nearly at the extreme you described. That is abuse, emotional and psychological, and probably physical too. You did the right thing. Keep calling the police, keep trying to find out where this wench lives. You may be saving a child's life.
ReplyDeletehorrifiying story. keep calling the police.
ReplyDeleteYou did the right thing. As hard as it was to do, you did the right thing. Hopefully now that you have an incident report the next time it happens, the police will arrive faster.
ReplyDelete